October 22, 2026
In the summer of 2024, Mercer Island's problem was water. The city asked people to stop running sprinklers, hold off on laundry for two days, and skip washing their cars. This winter the problem is getting down Gallagher Hill Road. Both trace back to the same 24-inch pipe.
On April 3, 2024, the city learned that the Seattle Public Utilities main had sprung a leak. That pipe carries water under the lake from Bellevue into the island's reservoirs. A local emergency was declared on May 1 over the reduced supply. The SPU line did not come back into service until August 1, after repairs and testing. By then the island had spent 120 days on its smaller backup supply.
The construction on Gallagher Hill since October 12 is the city's answer to that summer. According to the Mercer Island Reporter, project manager Ian Powell said the work is happening because of the 2024 failure. When it's finished, the city will own the new line and the old SPU line will be decommissioned. So the lane closures are what it costs to stop depending on a pipe Seattle owns.
The detours make more sense once you see the route. The city's project page says the new 24-inch line starts at the Boat Ramp area, runs north on East Mercer Way, then west on SE 36th Street. From there it climbs southwest up SE Gallagher Hill Road to SE 40th Street and continues east on SE 40th to 92nd Avenue SE. The project also moves the SPU master meter and replaces a 12-inch section at 89th Avenue SE and SE 43rd Street with 24-inch pipe.
The water comes up from the lakeshore toward the reservoirs, and Gallagher Hill sits on that path. That's why the hill gets the longest disruption, and why the work has to happen in a set order.
The 24-inch pipe can't go in until older pipe is replaced first. The first job is replacing an asbestos concrete line on Gallagher Hill Road with a new 10-inch ductile main. The city's scope covers about 1,500 feet of old 8-inch and 10-inch pipe and a new large pressure-reducing valve at the bottom of the hill. It also extends the pipeline to the top of the hill, with a new connection where SE 40th Street meets SE Gallagher Hill Road. The prime contractor is Scarsella Brothers, Inc., with Kar-Vel Construction as subcontractor.
Powell described how the two phases overlap in the Reporter story:
"The 24-inch goes from the boat ramp all the way up Gallagher Hill, so they're probably going to start about a month behind this (first) phase, and then start chasing them up the hill. So there will be a point in time where they're both kind of going."
Two crews will be working the same hill for part of the winter. That overlap is why the traffic pattern will change more than once.
The first three dates below have already happened. Everything after them is an estimate from the city or the Reporter, and the city says it will announce detour changes as they happen.
The city expects the roadway impacts to last up to six months. Its pre-construction notice said it did not expect night work.
The early-November change matters most. For a stretch of the project, Powell told the Reporter, one lane on Gallagher Hill will be closed 24 hours a day. "You will only be able to drive up the hill and not down, and traffic will be detoured down 40th, down Mercerwood and around," he said.
The city's version is more specific. If you're heading downhill toward the businesses on SE 36th Street or toward I-90, you'll be sent down Mercerwood Drive to East Mercer Way. Uphill traffic keeps its lane.
The city's earlier September notices said the hill would drop to one uphill lane, while the latest road update describes a few weeks of two-way flagging first. Check the current alert before you assume either one.
If you're going to the cluster of places near SE 36th Street and East Mercer Way, the city says this phase won't affect you directly, though trips may take a little longer. It names the Stroum Jewish Community Center, the French American School of Puget Sound, Bright Horizons, and County Village Day School. School buses will keep running, though some routes and travel times may change.
For nearly everyone, nothing changes. Powell told the Reporter there shouldn't be any water disruptions for Islanders beyond one exception. On a single day, eight Gallagher Hill homes will be without water from 9 a.m. to 3 p.m., and those households have received letters from the city.
Compare that with 2024. That July, after a spike in demand, the city made an urgent request for residents and businesses to cut back so it wouldn't have to impose mandatory restrictions. Reservoir levels had recovered by July 10. Even then, the city asked people to water no more than three times a week on an odd/even address schedule. This time, apart from that one day for eight homes, the disruption is on the roads and the island's water keeps running.
One more change comes with the switch. Shorewood Apartments currently buys water wholesale directly from SPU. Through this project it will get a new connection and become a city water customer.
After the water line is installed, tested, and started up, the roads get rebuilt, and to a better standard than before. The city's scope lists three segments:
That adds up to about 0.9 miles of repaved arterial road. Gallagher Hill will have a sidewalk on its downhill side and a bike shoulder on its uphill side, and SE 40th will have sidewalks and bike lanes on both sides.
The money comes from two places. The total budget is about $22 million, according to a council agenda bill cited by the Reporter. The water work is paid for by water utility rates, the Water Fund, state grants and bond proceeds. The pedestrian improvements come separately from the Street Fund.
The phases overlap and the dates are estimates, so the most useful thing to do is sign up for the city's free text alerts. The Public Works group covers water, sewer, parks and street disruptions, and standard text and data rates may apply. The city says it will post significant detour changes across its channels and notify neighbors and the Mercer Island School District directly. The project page lists City Customer Service at 206-275-7600 and Ian Powell, the utilities engineer, at 206-275-7813.
If you live along Gallagher Hill, SE 36th or SE 40th and you're wondering how this winter's construction and the new sidewalks will affect your own plans for your home, I'm happy to talk it through with you. Krissy Ayad is here when you're ready. Let's Connect.
Stay up to date on the latest real estate trends.
Krissy combines a calm, welcoming approach with sharp negotiation skills and local expertise to make achieving your real estate goals simple, stress-free, and rewarding.